‘American Idol’ tries breathing life into retread but fails

Fox’s “American Idol” once dominated television and even inspired website “Vote for the Worst” as it had become that much of a pop culture force.

It was even the inspiration for a New Yorker cartoonist.

new yorker american idol cartoon
Source: The New Yorker

“The voices in my head want to sing on ’American Idol,” a patient confides to his shrink in a 2006 Leo Cullum panel, proof of its cultural imprint.

Only two years after the singing contest ended its run on Fox amid dwindling ratings (not to mention newcomer “The Voice” was much more interesting) and steep production costs, it’s getting the chance to prove itself again in an ABC version debuting 8 p.m. EST Sunday. In the early episodes, the show is marginally revised and instantly familiar.

This “American Idol” retains the show’s original host, Ryan Seacrest, along with the same logo and production companies. Also intact is the goal of finding a music star — one such as Carrie Underwood, who built a blockbuster career after winning “Idol” in 2005 and whose voice-over opens the ABC show. Other superstars who can credit “Idol” with their start are Kelly Clarkson, Jennifer Hudon, Katharine McPhee, Jordin Sparks, Adam Lambert along with Chris Daughtry. Others have had quick moments in the spotlight which flickered out, but a handful have had long sustaining careers in the music industry.

The reboot’s early episodes include pre-taped auditions held in cities including New York; Savannah, Georgia; Los Angeles and New Orleans. We see, as before, crowds of would-be contestants eager to prove they have what it takes for a “golden ticket to Hollywood” and next-round tryouts.

“There’s been a lot of talk about how is this show different,” Seacrest said at a news conference with next-generation judges Luke Bryan, Katy Perry and Lionel Richie. “You’ve got three different faces. You have different contestants. But to change the show drastically in terms of format, I think, would be a mistake.”

(The show arrives under a #MeToo shadow for Seacrest. A woman who worked as his wardrobe stylist at E! News nearly a decade ago suggested he engaged in inappropriate behavior, which Seacrest has denied. The E! channel said an investigation found insufficient evidence to support the claims.)

katy perry vs nuns

Not helping matters for ABC is Katy Perry’s controversial ongoing battle against a group of nuns over property. On Friday, Sister Catherine Rose Holzman collapsed and died in a courtroom after appealing to Perry asking the singer to “please stop” her purchase of a $14.5 million 8-acre parcel of land in Los Angeles. The nuns had lived there up until 2011 when they were evicted by the archdiocese.

The fact that it’s been widely reported Perry is receiving $25 million as a judge on the show taints her image in this battle with nuns. Even Ryan Seacrest balked at her salary as he is only receiving $15 million while country singer Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie are scraping the barrel with $7 million each.

For the judges, the new “American Idol” represents a chance to put their stamp on a job held by a succession of celebrity panelists.

“I think we can inspire people and show people how it’s done too, in our own way,” Bryan told media outlets

Richie said the goal is to find more than a singer: “We are looking for an artist, and that’s going to require our expertise.”

The judges also may help the contestants set new goals, Perry said.

“Some people, they don’t know that there are other lanes in the freeway so it’s not just pop stardom,” she said. “Maybe you’re a Broadway star; maybe you’re in voiceover, maybe you’re gonna do jingles. Maybe you’re a songwriter. … There’s so many different ways to go at it.”

american idol tries kicking a dead horse badly

What ABC wants is more predictable: Ratings proof that it made the right decision in reviving “American Idol,” which first debuted in 2002 with judges Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell and Randy Jackson.

It reigned as TV’s No. 1 series for nine years, peaking with 30 million viewers an episode in 2006. By its last season the average audience had dipped to 11 million and skewed older, and NBC’s “The Voice” surpassed it in popularity. In today’s expanded field of cable and streaming options, however, an audience of 11 million would rank it among TV’s top 20 shows.

“‘American Idol’ is a pop-culture staple that left the air too soon,” Channing Dungey, ABC entertainment president, said in announcing the reboot last spring. “ABC is the right home to re-ignite the fan base.”

It was Seacrest who hinted on Fox’s May 2016 finale that there might be more “Idol” to come. “Good night, America. For now,” he said as the screen faded to black after Trent Harmon’s victory over runner-up La’Porsha Renae.

The voting audience had spoken, as they did in season one when Kelly Clarkson prevailed over Justin Guarini. Now it’s “American Idol” hoping once more to be crowned a winner.

Perry believes the timing is right.

“It’s about finding an actual ‘Idol,’ making that good old American dream come to life once again that we all can be inspired by,” she said. “We need those beautiful stories right now to help lift us up, inspire us, and believe in ourselves again.”

Many will more than likely watch the premiere out of curiosity, but expect the ratings to dwindle down again as Monday night continues the current season of “The Voice.” At the end “American Idol” tried a nicer approach (much like “The Voice”) so if you’re returning to it after sticking with it to the end, it will feel like it never left the air, and that’s not a good thing. Even “The Voice” knows how to mix things up to keep the show fresh.